The Cheat Sheet (The Cheat Sheet #1)

Sarah Adams 

The Cheat Sheet is one of Sarah Adams’ most successful romantic comedies, and it earns that praise through a perfect mix of humor, longing, friendship, and emotional vulnerability. Bree Camden and Nathan Donelson have built their lives around each other, but both are terrified to confess how they truly feel.

Bree is an incredibly lovable heroine. She is chaotic, warm, loyal, and embarrassingly unaware that her NFL superstar best friend has been in love with her for years. Her inner monologue is funny without being cartoonish, which makes her feel like someone you would genuinely want to befriend. Sarah writes about Bree’s insecurities with care, especially the way she undervalues herself and struggles to believe she is worthy of Nathan’s attention beyond friendship.

Nathan is one of Adam’s most swoon-worthy heroes. On the field, he is confident, but off it, he is gentle in every interaction with Bree. In turn, the way he supports her, protects her, and quietly sacrifices for her creates a depth that makes the romance feel earned. Finally, when he finally starts confronting his feelings, the emotional payoff is incredibly rewarding.

One of the strongest elements of this book is the way Adams balances humor and heart. For example, the comedic scenes are genuinely funny, especially the viral moment that launches the fake dating storyline. Yet the book never loses sight of the emotional stakes. Instead, every humorous moment pushes Bree and Nathan toward vulnerable conversations, and every vulnerable moment strengthens the romantic tension. The push and pull between them feels natural and addictive.

Overall, the supporting cast contributes to the atmosphere without overshadowing the main couple. Nathan’s teammates add levity and camaraderie, while Bree’s dance studio life brings warmth and grounding. Together, these side characters help build a world that feels full and lived in, something Adams consistently excels at.

The Cheat Sheet is a comfort read in the best sense. It is funny, heartfelt, deeply romantic, and wonderfully paced. It captures the thrill of falling in love with your best friend and the fear that comes with risking the relationship you treasure most. This book remains a fan favorite for a reason.

Rating: 4/5 Game Day Jerseys ✨

Ready to rent or buy this book?