Piper Rayne
If you love a heartfelt sports romance that blends fake dating, found family, and slow-burn chemistry, then you have to read The Hotshot.
Plot: When Leighton’s cousin and her husband pass away, Leighton suddenly becomes the legal guardian of their three young children. A compassionate but overwhelmed labor and delivery nurse, she’s determined to keep the kids together. Even if it means proving to the court she can provide a stable two-parent household. Hayes Carlisle, a confident and steady professional baseball catcher (and her best friend’s older brother), has always had feelings for Leighton. When he offers to fake date her to strengthen her custody case, it quickly turns into something much deeper. Hayes steps naturally into a supportive role with both Leighton and the kids. I love how Leighton steps up; she’s such a good FMC, and I loved her so much. And Hayes, he’s the definition of he falls first, is there to support her and be her number one fan.
Thoughts: I thought that the beginning was a little bit hard to get into with all the setup and custody details. But the family dynamic between Hayes and Leighton is adorable, and I completely fell in love with them. Watching Hayes bond with the kids and quietly support Leighton really sold the romance for me. Minus one star for how slow the beginning felt, but overall it’s such a heartwarming, emotional sports romance.
The steam absolutely delivers, but what really stood out was the emotional payoff. Beneath Hayes’s easy confidence and Leighton’s determination to hold everything together, there’s real vulnerability, growth, and heart. Watching Hayes show up not just as the fake boyfriend but as someone the kids and Leighton can truly rely on was a masterpiece.
If you’re into swoony pro athletes, strong heroines navigating real-life struggles, and a romance that balances heat with healing family moments, The Hotshot deserves a spot on your TBR.
Rating: 4.5/5 Catches✨